I LOOOOVE!! I've been using this product since late September and early February now, I still have it and I still love it. I initially used it under my makeup as a part of the prepping process to keep my wonderous oils at bay, that decision was partly based on another's review saying it'll be ashy on darker skin tones. Now that I've tried it to set my full face, I feel that I've debunked a myth works perfectly. I also can't tell which way is better I suppose that'll be based on preference, also a little goes a long way its a great product in every mineral that is comprised of its makeup. So glad to have it, if you're on the fence I hope I was able to confirm your judgment.